The Pros and Cons of Dropping Collision Coverage on Older Cars

Dropping collision coverage on older cars can be a smart financial move, but it comes with important trade-offs. Here are the main pros and cons, based on the latest expert guidance for 2025:

Pros of Dropping Collision Coverage	Cons of Dropping Collision Coverage
Lower insurance premiums: Eliminating collision can save you hundreds per year, especially if your car’s value is low.	No coverage for at-fault accidents: You’ll pay out of pocket for repairs if you cause an accident.
Makes sense for low-value vehicles: If your car’s value is less than 10x the annual collision premium, or just a few thousand dollars, the cost of coverage often outweighs potential payouts.	Risk of financial strain: If you can’t afford to repair or replace your car after a crash, you could be left without transportation.
Good for rarely driven or backup vehicles: If you drive infrequently or have another car, the risk is lower and coverage may not be necessary.	No payout if your car is totaled: If your car is a total loss, you’ll receive nothing from your insurer for your own vehicle.
Ideal if you can self-insure: If you have enough savings to cover repairs or replacement, you can take on the risk yourself.	Potential regret after an accident: If you drop coverage and then have a major accident, the savings may not offset the loss.
Not required by law: Once your car loan is paid off, you’re not obligated to carry collision coverage.	Required if you have a loan or lease: Dropping coverage on a financed or leased vehicle can violate your contract.

Key Decision Factors

Car’s Value: If your car’s value is low (e.g., less than $2,000–$3,000), collision coverage is often not cost-effective.
Premium vs. Value: If your annual collision premium is more than 10% of your car’s value, consider dropping it.
Deductible Size: High deductibles reduce the value of a payout, making coverage less worthwhile for older cars.
Financial Situation: Only drop coverage if you can afford to repair or replace your car out of pocket.
Driving Habits: If you drive less (retired, remote work, etc.), your risk is lower and dropping coverage makes more sense.
Loan/Lease Status: Never drop collision if your car is financed or leased—lenders require it.

Expert Tips

Check your car’s current market value before making a decision.
If you drop collision, consider saving the premium difference in a dedicated account for future repairs or a replacement.
Keep comprehensive coverage if you’re more concerned about non-collision risks like theft or weather damage.

In summary: Dropping collision coverage on an older, low-value car can reduce your insurance costs, but only makes sense if you can handle repair or replacement expenses yourself and don’t have a loan or lease. Always weigh the potential savings against your ability to absorb a loss.

AUTO INSURANCE

The Pros and Cons of Dropping Collision Coverage on Older Cars

Key Decision Factors

Expert Tips

You need to be a member of AUTO INSURANCE to add comments!

About