Auto Insurance Quote Reviews: Best Companies Ranked for 2025

Based on comprehensive analytics, customer satisfaction surveys, and expert reviews, the top auto insurance companies for 2025 are as follows:

1. 

•  8.9/10 (The Zebra), consistently topping customer surveys.

•  Exceptional customer service, affordable rates for military members and their families, accident forgiveness, and robust safe driver discounts.

•  Only available to military personnel, veterans, and their families.

2. 

•  8.8/10 (The Zebra), 8.5/10 (regional ranking).

•  High satisfaction, competitive pricing, strong regional reputation, and a unique rate-lock feature to prevent unexpected premium hikes.

•  Regional—primarily in the Northeast and Midwest.

3. 

•  8.4/10 (The Zebra).

•  Personalized agent support, unique coverages (accidental death, travel protection), and a usage-based discount program.

4. 

•  8.3/10 (The Zebra), highly rated for claims and service.

•  Nationwide availability, strong digital tools, and excellent claims satisfaction.

•  Teen drivers and those seeking a large agent network.

5. 

•  Ranked best overall by NerdWallet and MarketWatch for 2025.

•  Broad coverage options, competitive rates, and strong financial stability.

6. 

•  Best for customer satisfaction and claims experience, according to J.D. Power and Business Insider.

•  High claims satisfaction and a long history in the industry.

7. 

•  Affordable coverage, strong digital experience, and highly rated for New York and national markets.

•  Affordable rates and digital-savvy customers.

8. 

•  Best for accident forgiveness and telematics programs, with a wide range of discounts.

9. 

• Farmers, Liberty Mutual, Allstate, and AAA also score well for specific customer segments or regional strengths.

• USAA, Erie, and American Family lead in customer satisfaction.

• Travelers, State Farm, and Amica are top choices for broad coverage and claims satisfaction.

•  excel in affordability and digital tools.

• Always compare quotes and consider both price and service reputation for the best value in 2025 auto insurance