Auto Insurance Quote Reviews: Best Companies Ranked for 2025
Based on comprehensive analytics, customer satisfaction surveys, and expert reviews, the top auto insurance companies for 2025 are as follows:
1.
8.9/10 (The Zebra), consistently topping customer surveys.
Exceptional customer service, affordable rates for military members and their families, accident forgiveness, and robust safe driver discounts.
Only available to military personnel, veterans, and their families.
2.
8.8/10 (The Zebra), 8.5/10 (regional ranking).
High satisfaction, competitive pricing, strong regional reputation, and a unique rate-lock feature to prevent unexpected premium hikes.
Regional—primarily in the Northeast and Midwest.
3.
8.4/10 (The Zebra).
Personalized agent support, unique coverages (accidental death, travel protection), and a usage-based discount program.
4.
8.3/10 (The Zebra), highly rated for claims and service.
Nationwide availability, strong digital tools, and excellent claims satisfaction.
Teen drivers and those seeking a large agent network.
5.
Ranked best overall by NerdWallet and MarketWatch for 2025.
Broad coverage options, competitive rates, and strong financial stability.
6.
Best for customer satisfaction and claims experience, according to J.D. Power and Business Insider.
High claims satisfaction and a long history in the industry.
7.
Affordable coverage, strong digital experience, and highly rated for New York and national markets.
Affordable rates and digital-savvy customers.
8.
Best for accident forgiveness and telematics programs, with a wide range of discounts.
9.
Farmers, Liberty Mutual, Allstate, and AAA also score well for specific customer segments or regional strengths.
Rank |
Company |
Customer Satisfaction (out of 10) |
1 |
USAA |
8.9 |
2 |
Erie |
8.8 |
3 |
American Family |
8.4 |
4 |
AAA |
8.4 |
5 |
State Farm |
8.3 |
6 |
GEICO |
8.2 |
7 |
Farmers |
8.2 |
8 |
Liberty Mutual |
8.1 |
9 |
Allstate |
8.1 |
10 |
Travelers |
8.1 |
USAA, Erie, and American Family lead in customer satisfaction.
Travelers, State Farm, and Amica are top choices for broad coverage and claims satisfaction.
excel in affordability and digital tools.
Always compare quotes and consider both price and service reputation for the best value in 2025 auto insurance
You need to be a member of AUTO INSURANCE to add comments!
Join AUTO INSURANCE